
At 5 feet, 8 inches — or a couple inches shorter, depending on the report — Alexia Amarista is going to have a hard time getting noticed by scouts and prospect hounds, unless he does something special. How about the fourth-best statistical performance by an Angels prospect since 2005?
According to Halos Heaven’s rghan, the 20-year-old Amarista did just that, winning his league’s batting title and his league’s equivalent of the Gold Glove at low-A Cedar Rapids this season. And in rghan’s annual ranking of minor league performances, Amarista tops the list.
These are much different than prospect rankings. For ranking purposes, rghan doesn’t get into the scouting reports, body types or pedigrees, but simply rates the performance in the context of each minor league level. (He does talk about those things in each player’s write-up, so do click through.)
Here’s No. 32-21, No. 20-11, and his top 10:
10. Michael Kohn, RH RP, low-A
9. Dillon Baird, 1B, rookie ball
8. Robert Mosebach, RH RP, AA and AAA
7. Peter Bourjos, CF, AA
6. Trevor Bell, RHP, Double- and AAA
5. Trevor Reckling, LHP, High-A and AA
4. Alexander Torres, LHP, High-A and AA*
3. Sean Rodriguez, utility, AAA*
2. Carlos Ramirez, C, rookie ball
1. Amarista
Other notables: Brandon Wood at No. 14, 17-year-old Mike Trout at No. 15, and top pick Randal Grichuk at No. 32. Again, these are not prospect ratings. Ramirez, for instance, has all of 200 professional at bats, he was 21 years old playing short-season ball, and he mashed in a hitters league. Don’t expect anybody to rank him ahead of Reckling or Trout this winter. Generally speaking, the lower the level, the less predictive the raw stats are.
Here’s last year’s list, too.
*Torres and Rodriguez were both traded away in the Scott Kazmir deal.
Brandon Wood shouldn’t be included by most standards because he long ago lost his rookie status. Baseball America, for example, uses the MLB rule which is no more than 130 ABs in the majors. Wood has 224. MLB also has a rule that the player has spent no more than 45 days on a major league roster during the 25-man limit (i.e. before September 1).
I’m researching and writing now the annual FutureAngels.com Top 10 Prospects report. It should be done in a couple weeks. Some difficult calls to make, choosing between all the picks in the 2009 draft first round versus guys in the system for a while.
As a P.S., for those who want to see Amarista, here are my photos of him from 2008:
http://www.futureangels.com/digital/a/amaristaa.aspx
As part of my research, I spoke with a Midwest League manager (not with the Angels) and he compared Amarista to Hainley Statia. He thinks Amarista’s ceiling is as a utility player, probably a 2B in the infield. I saw him play right field at Rookie-A Tempe in 2008.
And for what it’s worth, I agree he’s shorter than 5′8″. Maybe 5′6″. Somewhere in Freddie Patek territory.
Unless he is playing for the organization’s basketball team, his height means little to me … and should not bother a franchise that has fielded Albie Pearson, Fred Patek and David Eckstein. And it seems to me Dustin Pedroia was pretty good for an AL contender in 2008.